Two high-profile London design competitions for the Geffrye Museum and Crystal Palace have attracted just shy of 180 entries
More from: Wright & Wright wins Geffrye Museum job
It was confirmed earlier this week that the much-publicised search for a new team to take on the overhaul of the Geffrye Museum in Hackney, east London had received nearly 140 entries.
The re-run became necessary after Hackney Council’s planning commitee refused Chipperfield’s £14 million extension to the Grade I-listed museum back in May 2013. The scheme had included the controversial demolition of an adjacent pub.
Councillors said Chipperfield’s plans would ‘result in the loss of architectural and historic features and would adversely affect the character of the museum’, which sits within the Kingsland Conservation Area.
So in December museum bosses decided they needed a ‘new approach’ to the project.
The new competition opens up the possibility that Stanton Williams, Dixon Jones and Wilkinson Eyre will have a second stab at the scheme after being beaten by Chipperfield on the original shortlist.
A spokesperson said the museum would be ‘shortlisting the applications over the next couple of months and we will make an announcement on who we have appointed at the beginning of April’.
Meanwhile, to the south of the city, an international competition to recreate Crystal Palace has begun in earnest with news that 40 entries have been received for the £500million development which also includes the rejuvenation of the surrounding park land.
In October London Mayor Boris Johnson revealed that the Chinese Zhang Rong Group (ZRG) was planning to recreate a ‘culture-led exhibition and employment space’ that will become a ‘major new cultural destination for the capital.’
At the time of the launch, Arup director (Arup is advising ZRG) said that the historic importance and sensitivity of the scheme would favour a ‘big UK architect’.
Fresh start’ as Geffrye Museum hunts for Chipperfield’s replacement (AJ 17.12.13)
The Geffrye Museum has relaunched its search for an architect after dropping David Chipperfield Architects last month
The east London museum has revised the project’s brief and is now looking for a new architect to work on the expansion programme.
The 1,300m² development will create an entrance opposite Hoxton Station, new spaces for the museum’s collections, a gallery, restaurant, and conference facilities.
The former pub at 32 Cremer Street, which was controversially due to be demolished as part of Chipperfield’s plans, will be kept in the new development.
The museum initially said it was considering an appeal following Hackney Council’s refusal in May for Chipperfield’s proposed £18.9million extension to the Grade I-listed museum. However last month museum bosses decided to they wanted a ‘new approach’ to the project.
Museum director David Dewing said: ‘We have enjoyed a very productive relationship with David Chipperfield Architects. But sadly, the scheme we worked up together failed to secure planning permission. So in discussion with David Chipperfield, we feel a fresh start is needed.
‘We will be selecting new architects with a modified brief in the coming months and submitting a new application to the Heritage Lottery Fund. We are feeling confident and reinvigorated about taking the project forward for the benefit of our visitors in Hackney and beyond.’
The planning committee had said Chipperfield’s plans would ‘result in the loss of architectural and historic features and would adversely affect the character of the museum’, which sites within the Kingsland Conservation Area.
The masterplan for the scheme was originally drawn up by Chipperfield back in 2010, after they beat off competition from Wilkinson Eyre, Dixon Jones and Stanton Williams, to win the job.
Previous story (02.05.13)
Appeal ‘an option’ after Chipperfield’s Geffrye Museum plans rejected
The Geffrye Museum is considering an appeal after Hackney Council rejected plans by David Chipperfield to extend the east London museum
Last night (1 May) councillors voted six to two in favour of throwing out the contentious £18.9 million expansion plans which would have seen a two-storey building added to the existing Grade I-listed museum and included the demolition of a former pub at 32 Cremer Street.
The committee said the scheme, which Chipperfield started working on in 2009 (see below), would ‘result in the loss of architectural and historical features on a listed building’ and ‘adversely affect the character’ of the museum which sits in the Kingsland Conservation Area.
In response the museum said it was considering its options including whether to appeal and confirmed it was in ‘on-going discussions with the Heritage Lottery Fund’.
David Dewing, director of the Geffrye said: ‘We are bitterly disappointed. We passionately believe that our proposed scheme would have provided great opportunities and benefits to the local community, creating a much stronger, better museum, attracting more visitors and generating more investment into the Borough.
He added: ‘The new building by David Chipperfield promised to bring world-class architecture into the heart of Hackney. The decision by the planning committee denies the essential progress which keeps great cities vibrant and dynamic. We are now considering our options carefully. Our priority remains to develop the Geffrye Museum for the benefit of our visitors and the wider community and to ensure the buildings, gardens and collections are opened up to wider audiences.’
Read the full reasons for refusal here.
Previous story (AJ 28.06.2011)
Chipperfield to extend Geffrye Museum
David Chipperfield has been appointed to design exhibition spaces and a new library for the Geffrye Museum in London
Scheduled to completed in 2015, the ‘Museum of the Home’ project aims to establish the museum as a centre for ‘learning and discovery’, upgrading its circulation spaces and creating a new entrance addressing the recently opened Hoxton Railway Station nearby.
David Chipperfield said: ‘We are delighted to have been appointed by the Geffrye Museum to further our work that started with the masterplan in 2009 leading to a detailed proposal for this unique institution.’
David Dewing, Geffrye Museum director added: ‘This is an important and challenging journey for the museum, and we are delighted to be working with David Chipperfield and his team on this exciting project.
‘Their approach is thoughtful, clear and highly professional. David Chipperfield Architects show great confidence in their ability to resolve the complicated and sensitive planning and design issues involved with creating innovative interventions whilst maintaining the quality and integrity of the Geffrye’s existing buildings and gardens.’
The project won Heritage Lottery Fund backing in May.
Geffrye Museum and Crystal Palace comps attract slew of entrants