Islington Council has revealed the four winning ideas in its competition to find concepts for the £1 million transformation of Old Street roundabout
The winning schemes – drawn up by Dar, Gpad London, Nicholas Hare Architects and EPR Architects – were chosen from a longlist of 39 submissions, which included Allford Hall Monaghan Morris, Zaha Hadid Architects and Hawkins\Brown (full longlist below).
The four selected designs were praised by the judges for striking the right balance between ‘iconic and achievable’ and creating ‘flexible and inclusive spaces, prioritising people and pedestrians, [and] making cyclists feel welcome’.
However, according to the local authority, a separate tender process with the same judges and ’informed by the open call process’ will now be launched to take the project forward.
A separate tender process will now be launched to take the project forward
The competition invited multidisciplinary teams of architects, artists, designers and technologists to submit ‘exciting, bold and iconic’ proposals for a new gateway structure or public artwork reflecting the area’s identity as a hub for digital innovation.
The project is part of ambitious plans to close the north-western arm of the congested roundabout to create a new pedestrian plaza and entrance to the busy underground station. It is supported by the Mayor of London, Transport for London (TfL) and Hackney Council. Proposals were permitted to exceed the £1 million budget if suitable options for additional funding were identified by the applicant.
Judging the competition were Claudia Webbe, Islington Council’s executive member for environment and transport; Feryal Demirci, Hackney councillor and cabinet member for neighbourhoods; Will Norman, London’s walking and cycling commissioner; and Allison Dutoit from Gehl Architects.
Webbe said: ‘Old Street is an iconic place, known across the world as a vibrant hub of technology and culture, and it inspired many bold and exciting design ideas for our open call.
‘In an extremely competitive field, the judging panel has selected the entries that we believe offer the best ideas to create an ‘iconic gateway’ for Old Street with a much improved environment for local people, cyclists and commuters, alongside the wider transformation of Old Street. We thank everyone who took part in this open call and has played a part in helping to shape the future of Old Street.’
Norman said: ‘Our transformation of Old Street is going to make this notorious roundabout easier, safer and more pleasant for Londoners to walk and cycle. It’s a great example of what we’re looking to achieve right across the capital.
‘Islington’s open call has been a great way to generate designs to further enhance this new public space. I’d like to congratulate the four winning designs on their innovative ideas.’
Demirci commented: ‘Together with Islington Council we are creating a low emission neighbourhood in Shoreditch, with ultra-low emission streets, roads closed to through traffic and improved public spaces.
‘However, the main roads also need to be made safer, so I’m looking forward to seeing Old Street transformed from a dangerous roundabout into a space which is safer and more pleasant to walk and cycle across.’
Old Street Roundabout is on the boundary of the London boroughs of Hackney and Islington at the junction of Old Street and City Road. It was created in the 1960s as part of an inner-city road improvement programme.
The complex – also known as Silicon Roundabout for the area’s density of high-tech start-ups – includes underground shops and station ticket hall, and a rooftop bar. The junction itself has been the site of many cycling accidents.
Five years ago, Architecture 00 mooted plans to transform the roundabout into a ‘start-up city’; while three years ago alma-nac, Ben Adams Architects, BuckleyGrayYeoman, Farrells and Hawkins\Brown participated in a separate call for concepts.
The latest project is part of plans to close the north-western arm of the roundabout and reintroduce two-way traffic. The closure – due to be implemented in 2019 – will create a pedestrianised peninsula and an improved entrance to the underground station, along with segregated cycle lanes and crossings.
Among the longlisted teams selected from more than 120 entries to the Islington Council-backed commission were AHMM, Zaha Hadid Architects, Hawkins\Brown, Mae, Tonkin Liu, Ayre Chamberlain Gaunt, EPR, GRID, Pilbrow & Partners, shedkm, and Gibson Thornley.
The 39 designs featured in a public exhibition inside AHMM’s White Collar Factory (2-4 Old Street Yard) earlier this year.
‘Old Street Circus 2050’ by Dar (led by Dar Landscape Design Team, with Perkins+Will, Portland Design, Elementa Consulting, Currie & Brown, Maffeis Engineering)
The Dar vison is to reclaim the roundabout area for people and to transform it into a genuinely useable, inclusive, healthy and safe public space hosting a wide range of activities such as film screenings, concerts, street-markets and festivals. The Dar proposal includes an iconic sculptural ring of light that will incorporate art, dynamic information, advertising and green infrastructure to create a new landmark for London.
‘Old Street Digital Garden’ by Gpad London (with Eyekon)
A forest of lights that generate electricity enveloping a new pavilion, a water feature, and a ‘digital totem’ shaped by turning the existing advertising screens on their ends to house an automated cycle parking structure.
‘Old Street Park’ by Nicholas Hare Architects (with Price & Myers, Hoare Lea, FIRA)
A flexible, green, smart public space for cyclists, residents, workers, and visitors that harnesses the social, environmental and economic aspirations of the area for the Old Street community.
‘The Iris’ by EPR Architects (with Martin Richman, Wayfindr, Modus Operandi, Gillespies, Entuitive, Materials Council, Stage One)
A piece of metropolitan land art centring around ‘The Iris’, a reflective lens facilitating interaction, inclusive gatherings, performances, play and relaxation.
|LEAD ARCHITECT||FULL TEAM||PROJECT TITLE|
|Allford Hall Monaghan Morris (AHMM) and Derwent London||Allford Hall Monaghan Morris (AHMM), Derwent London||AHMM AND Derwent London proposal for Old Street Roundabout|
|Atelier Chang||Atelier Chang, Bongsu Park, Oliver Curtis, Alex Doss, ClearLED, Pavegen||Tale Points|
|Ayre Chamberlain Gaunt Architects||Ayre Chamberlain Gaunt, LT Studio, University of Reading, Spacehive, Heyne Tillett Steel, Max Fordham, Charcoal Blue, Peter Brett Associates, Professor John Worthington MBE||Introvert-Extrovert|
|Brodie Plant Goddard||Brodie Plant Goddard||Nexus|
|Coffey Architects||Coffey Architects||Old Street Cloud|
|Cove Burgess Architects||Cove Burgess, Eco Cycle, Pell Frischmann||Silicon Hill|
|D*Haus Company||D*Haus Company||The Stone Circus|
|Dar Group||Dar, Perkins+Will, Portland Design, Elementa Consulting, Currie & Brown, Maffeis Engineering||Old Street Circus 2050|
|Djao-Rakitine||Djao-Rakitine, Arup, Urban Intelligence||Old Street Public Square:
Gateway to Smart Tech City
|EPR Architects||EPR Architects, Martin Richman, Wayfindr, Modus Operandi, Gillespies, Entuitive, Materials Council, Stage One||The Iris|
|Es Devlin Studio||Es Devlin Studio, Google Arts and Culture||The Infinite Library|
|Fereday Pollard (01)||Fereday Pollard||Art & Technology Hub|
|Fereday Pollard (02)||Fereday Pollard||Self-sustaining Botanical Farm with Art and Technology Platform|
|Fluid||Fluid, Trinity Design, Structure Mode, Momentum, SEAM, CAS (Contemporary Art
Society), London Wildlife Trust, Arup Digital, ISOBAR
|Old Street Pier|
|Gibson Thornley Architects||Gibson Thornley Architects, Kinnear Landscape Architects, Arup||Urban Oasis|
|Gpad London||Gpad London, Eyekon||Old Street Digital Garden|
|GRID Architects||GRID Architects||Hydroponiqa|
|Hawkins\Brown||Hawkins\Brown, Weber Industries, Studio Dekka, Melanie Wilson||Old Street Common|
|Horden Cherry Lee (HCL) Architects||HCL Architects||Silicon Circus|
|Intervention Architecture||Intervention Architecture||Lover’s Knot: At Light’s Edge|
|JaK Studio||JaK Studio, Seymour Powell, CAR, JaM Management, CollectConnect, Light IQ||COMM.ON|
|Mae||Mae, Planit IE, Max Fordham & Partners, One Works, Changebuilding||Old Street Common|
|Markwick Architects||Markwick Architects, Thomas Leung||Sustainable Urban Form|
|MRZ.ES||MRZ.ES||Sustainable Urban Form|
|MAX Architects||MAX Architects, Wildstone||Bildpunkt (Pixel)|
|Naza Architectura y Diseño||Naza Architectura y Diseño, Consultants: Leandro Morillas Moreno, Tarick Chahade, Philipp Schäfer, Rogelio Perez Barja, Gema Pariente Sánchez, Iván del Río, Javier Campillo Puente||Tech Forest|
|Nicholas Hare Architects||Nicholas Hare Architects, Price and Myers, Hoare Lea, FIRA||Old Street Park|
|Paul Cocksedge Studio (with Ben Adams Architects)||Paul Cocksedge Studio, Ben Adams Architects||Illuminated Arches|
|Perserverance Architects||Perseverance Architects, Taylor Whalley Spyra, Furness Green Partnership, Ares Landscape Architects, Creatmosphere||Silicon Towers|
|Pilbrow and Partners||Pilbrow & Partners, AKT II, Space Syntax, Motion Transportation, FutureCity||The Deck and Screen|
|Ruben Ramos Jimenez||Ruben Ramos, Lara Rooke, Ignacio Manrique, Maria Alonso, Xavier Tomassetti||Living the Leaves|
|A New Old Street: Where Promenade Meets Playground|
|Spaced Out||Spaced Out, Kisset Co, Andie Scott||Sowing the Seed|
|Sustrans||Sustrans, Lumenpulse Group||Hello, World!|
|Thor Architects||Thor Architects||Old Street Landscape Gateway|
|Tonkin Liu||Tonkin Liu, Arup, SEAM, Integration||Old Street New Tree|
|Urben Limited||Urben Limited, Miriam+Tom, 18 Degrees, Momentum Transport||The Stage @ Silicon Roundabout|
|What if: projects||What if: projects||Old Street Arena|
|Zaha Hadid Architects||Zaha Hadid Architects||Hect Aire|