Unsupported browser

For a better experience please update your browser to its latest version.

Your browser appears to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser

We'll assume we have your consent to use cookies, for example so you won't need to log in each time you visit our site.
Learn more


  • Comment

Margaret Hodge gives the AJ her first ever interview as the government's minister for architecture.

What do you think the role of an architecture minister is?

It is difficult to answer so early on, but I should stress how important place is to people, and buildings are a crucial part of place. Architecture has always been important in all my ministerial positions.

When I was children's minister (2003-05), CABE did a competition for us which the Abbey Centre won, and that has now set a benchmark for other buildings for children.

And actually, architecture is a really good discipline. You develop a whole range of skills - you have to have physics and maths and you've got to have social understanding.

We must remember we're jolly good at architecture in the UK. We have the Richard Rogers, the Norman Fosters and the Michael Hopkins, so we have a big tradition in it.

What kind of house do you live in?

I live in trendy old Islington. We bought before the boom and when we moved in the mortgage broker asked, 'Why are you moving into this house?' He thought we were bonkers.

It's an 1860s crescent and is terrifically flexible. When we first moved in I had two children and then went up to four. Now we're back to two of us, and we have managed to change the space and enjoy it.

And that is what is interesting.

There's an 1860s building which has proved flexible after 150 years.

How do you see the balance between development and protecting heritage?

Both are crucial. Obviously there's the debate going on in London on how you protect heritage with the influx of tall buildings.

I drive to Barking often and so drive past Canary Wharf, which I think is quite attractive. I watched it develop, and hated it and I still think they got an awful lot wrong.

They failed to put in any of the infrastructure. It was like going to a ghost town. Like a gated development, juxtaposed to Tower Hamlets. But I now quite like passing those buildings.

I still find them quite soulless. It's like when you fly into American cities, they all look a bit the same. The skyline is pretty similar with just a different array of tall buildings.

People on the whole don't want to engulf the Tower of London with tall buildings, but there is the other side - the Gherkin is very interesting.

These will be our monuments to the future.

What is important is that we value our past but also realise what we do in the present will create the legacy for the future. I'm not pro one or the other.

We have this wonderful heritage in London and we must make it work with exciting buildings of the future.

What are your thoughts on housing need and the role architecture has to play?

In my constituency in Barking, there is Barking Riverside. It won't work unless we get the DLR out there. That's where we went wrong in the Docklands.

We have a commitment from government but we now need the funding to emerge swiftly.

But then there is the design, and we cannot have a repeat of Bellway Homes [Barking Reach regeneration programme] houses, which was disappointing to say the least.

They have now learnt the lesson and they've brought this Dutch firm Maxwan to do a masterplan. It is now integrating housing - social housing to rent and housing to buy. But it shows that design really matters.

What I need for my constituents in regards to housing is the right to buy, and I've been very vocal recently.

There is a desperate shortage of affordable housing to rent. The legacy of right to buy has meant the loss of what was very good social housing. I think that is one of the major factors contributing to current community tensions, which has led to the rise of the BNP.

These people feel a huge lack of fairness. There is desperate need for affordable housing if you want to create community cohesion.

What are your thoughts on the sustainability agenda?

Another huge job, and it's not just new housing. There are 25 million homes, and even if we build 250,000 that's only 1 per cent. The challenge is cutting emissions from houses like mine.

Architects think of new housing, but what about existing housing? Domestic CO 2 output is one of the biggest contributions; I think it is 40 to 50 per cent of emissions.

And then you have to look at how the street works together as a whole to achieve lower CO emissions. Architecture needs to do more each year.

What do you think architects building vast housing projects today can learn from the mistakes from the 1960s?

It's really important that what we build works for people.

There is the Marquess Estate in Islington: I was at Islington Council at the time, and Harold Wilson gave it an award, but it's now being torn down. It was an absolute disaster. It was full of walkways: when people want streets, they want their defensible space, such as gardens etc.

Which current regeneration projects have impressed you most?

Well, what I would look at from my own constituency in Barking, is Jo Richardson's school and what is so great about it, it's a school that's bang in the middle of a very difficult area. It's a community school and has within it a library, a police station, community facilities and children's centre.

It works terrifically well.

On the other hand I have a new PFI hospital in Romford, and it was a real triumph getting it. But I think that demonstrates our design failures in the PFI programme - there's nine miles of corridor! Who goes to hospital? You're either old or unwell or on crutches! So I hope these new local walk-in centres do a better job.

Architecture is a very maleorientated profession, as is politics.

From your own experiences how can women develop more of a foothold in the industry?

I didn't realise it still was. There has been a change in other professions, medicine and law due to girls outperforming boys at school, but I wasn't aware there still was such a gap in architecture. It obviously isn't just young women not starting, there are glass ceilings, although I would have thought architecture ought to be something that you can do on a part-time basis to raise children or look after elderly relatives or whatever. That is a challenge for me.

What is your favourite city?

Siena. When you sit in the square at Siena, with the colour of stones and skyline, and the palace and the cathedral, there is nothing more delicious. It is also the exibility of stunning heritage moving into modern architecture.

It's that integration of the past and present and looking into the future. Just sitting in those restaurants and bars looking at the world go by.

What are your thoughts on the Mayor's public spaces programme?

I think they are hugely important - how we set up the legacy for future generations.

But it's also people's sense of wellbeing and identity with space.

In my constituency, they feel they don't have affordable housing. While I value the public spaces programme, you must construct a consensus that it is a worthwhile investment.

What's your favourite building?

That's too difficult. There are far too many! What's yours?


8 September 1944: Born Cairo, Egypt 1973 to 1979: Elected to Islington Council. Appointed chair of Islington Council Housing Committee in 1975 1981 to 1982: Islington Council deputy leader 1982 to1992: Council leader 1994: Elected MP for Barking 1998 to 2001: Under secretary for employment and equal opportunities, Department for Education and Employment 2001 to 2003: Minister for lifelong learning, further and higher education, Department for Education and Skills 2003 to 2005: Minister for children, young people and families, Department for Education and Skills 2005 to 2006: Minister for employment and welfare reform, Department for Work and Pensions 2006 to 10 July 2007: Minister for industry, Department for Trade and Industry 2007: Minister for architecture, Department of Culture, Media and Sport

  • Comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Please remember that the submission of any material is governed by our Terms and Conditions and by submitting material you confirm your agreement to these Terms and Conditions.

Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.