Don't be so miserable! They have even put a cornice on the elevation to tie the buildings together - a planner's default that works very well on this occasion. Your comment about scale is what one would expect from a greenhorn planner, even though the form of the new design seems from the illustrations to be both imaginative and appropriate
That's the scariest thing I've seen for quite a while. Perhaps some imaginative PR is required from the developer - how about The Dreaming Spires of Ealing.......
Comment on: Twickenham Riverside contest designs revealed
It's difficult to judge six schemes for the same site with only perspectives to go on, and with no background on the differences in briefs between the schemes. But, on the evidence presented, Francis Terry's scheme wipes the floor with the current five proposals, none of which demonstrate anything like Terry's understanding of how to address the river, use appropriate scale when viewed from the river or its banks, create coherent form, proportion, massing and above all a real sense of place-making.
The current five range from feeble but inoffensive to downright horrendous.
I,m not suggesting that Terry has the only answer - in the last couple of decades there has been a growing awareness among some modern architects of the lessons of history (eg Ancient Greece and Rome, Italian hill towns), in particular relating to place-making and the civic realm.
The current five schemes completely fail to address the huge potential of this exceptional site. None of them are anywhere near good enough, and the promoters need to start again
It's not a Tulip
It's a Q-Tip
It's also off the scale that starts with ugly and ends with hideous.
Its single virtue would be to pull the eye away for a second or two from the surrounding cluster of monstrosities which together so eloquently express the triumphant chaos of international speculative finance, and the murder of the civic realm....
I'm confused. The text talks about 'light touch', preserving the existing (iconic) design and so on. Completely appropriate for such an important building.
The visuals show everything existing covered up in grey render, wood laminate suspended ceiling panels of the wrong shape - the whole looking like the departure lounge to Hell.
We are being seriously misled one way or the other.