By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

Your browser seems to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser.


Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.


Walter Menteth

Walter Menteth

Recent activity

Comments (12)

  • Comment on: Poll: architects say new schools fail to make the grade

    Walter Menteth's comment 2-Apr-2015 11:36 am

    AJ great for highlighting this atrocious lack of quality and social value with the governments PSBP. evidences EFA’s anti-competitive procurement supply chain. Design, quality, engagement, choice, & competition required to deliver excellent schools can’t be delivered in a context where the EFA’s procurement is also centrally captured, controlled and driven by these anti-competitive construction practices. The problem extends well beyond design, brief and budget. The EFA PSBP programme is dysfunctional and should be scrapped

  • Comment on: International competition launched for Preston bus station

    Walter Menteth's comment 25-Feb-2015 3:01 pm

    Delighted to hear it will be a Design Contest - and the choice will be on the quality of design not on financial or other such criteria! Expand use of Design Contets and view new Design Contest Guidance published here

  • Comment on: Local architects blast ‘totally inappropriate’ beach huts PQQ

    Walter Menteth's comment 20-Jan-2015 11:22 am

    Another shocker! Inappropriate procurements like this are being actively investigated by The Cabinet Office Mystery Shopper Service (; but only in response to reports submitted to them. It is important therefore that the profession continues emailing complaints about all bad practices on a frequent basis if we are to ensure better future practices. They are responsive. The New Public Contract Regulations 2015 although delayed are due to come into force within the next 2 months. Neither PI or turnover will become mandatory requirements to bid. But old (bad) risk averse habits will likely die hard.

  • Comment on: Micro-homes: part of the solution or part of the problem?

    Walter Menteth's comment 16-Jan-2015 12:28 pm

    As Julia Parker reflects the failure of an adequate housing delivery system is central to this response to growing and unfulfilled needs for suitable affordable accommodation. But reducing the standard and quality of housing and life opportunities is a race to the bottom. This is driven by current supply imperatives and failures which in the widest context are unsustainable. If regarded as a generic housing solution, micro flats seem a desperate and expedient measure reflective of the times. Where it ends needs consideration. I would strongly suspect that few if any proponents of these sized flats have lived in such small accommodation, or would do so given the opportunity. Our profession has bursting enthusiasm to support creative engagement with problem solving. A danger is that sometimes we get placed in positions were we are unable to see the wood for the trees, which can lead to inappropriate solutions in social terms. Perhaps to many this might appear arrogant and architecturally deterministic; but repetition of some previous periods of historic failures should be avoided. Working together to increase pressure for decent affordable housing for all in the forthcoming election seems more relevant.

  • Comment on: Politicians to probe Heatherwick’s Garden Bridge appointment

    Walter Menteth's comment 12-Dec-2014 1:02 pm

    Something seems profoundly wrong here if this has been commissioned without public engagement or even a proper transparent public call?. As pointed out by Martin Knight AJ article 29 Oct the cost at £175m ‘is around 7 times that of the Millennium Bridge and, much better value might be gained in supporting multiple upgraded and new river crossings in a variety of locations, including the footbridge proposed between Pimlico and Nine Elms (by TfL estimate £40 m).’

View all comments