By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

Your browser seems to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser.


Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.


Scottish CABE sidelined in Dundee

Dundee City Council has marginalised Scottish design watchdog AD+S by granting planning permission to a controversial hotel and office proposal against the group's wishes.

The council has given the green light to the prominent city-centre development, despite AD+S' view at the end of last year that the application must 'not be rushed through' before 'more careful consideration'.

In December, the mixed-use scheme - designed by James F Stephens Architects - was felt by A+DS to lack 'sufficient architectural and place-making qualities to fully justify [its] critical position within the city and the council's ambitions for the future.'

The scheme comprises a 114-bedroom hotel, over 21,000m 2of office space and 103 off-street car parking spaces.

Despite the design watchdog's criticism, the council was happy, only a month later, to grant planning approval. Camlin Investments, the client, now hopes to start on site in May.

Given the site's close proximity to the railway station, bus routes and a new 600-space multi-storey car park, A+DS questioned the need for substantial on-site parking - viewing the building's rear use solely for car parking as a 'wasted opportunity'.

To satisfy its 'grave concerns' regarding the proposed building's height, A+DS requested 3D images showing the building in context; planning permission has been granted without these.

The watchdog also said that escape stairs should be relocated from their 'unacceptable' position at significant corner locations; project architect Doug Reed admitted to the AJ that no internal changes had taken place.

The council's decision to back the scheme, despite that fact that A+DS said it would not 'stitch successfully into the city fabric', will send shockwaves through the Scottish architectural scene.

A+DS has been in existence for less than 12 months and is currently attempting to secure a position in the Scottish planning system similar to that held by CABE south of the border.

by Will Hunter

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment.

The searchable digital buildings archive with drawings from more than 1,500 projects

AJ newsletters