By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

Plans to transform kitsch Grade II-listed Liberty landmark turned down

Liberty department store's controversial plan to radically transform its Grade II-listed mock-Tudor landmark home into a hotel has been rejected by Westminster City Council.

The scheme, devised by Anne Machin Architects, involves adding a sixth floor, including roof terrace, to the famously-kitsch 1924 store, which sits within the Regent Street Conservation Area near Carnaby Street.

It also proposes demolishing part of the shop, originally designed by Edwin T Hall and known simply as the Tudor Building.

Under Machin's controversial plans almost half the chintzy building would be redeveloped as a 41-bedroom boutique hotel, restaurant and bar. Moreover, part of the existing fabric of the building, on 26 Marlborough Street and 1A Little Marlborough Street, would be replaced with a modern, five-storey glazed building.

However, Westminster's planning committee blocked the proposal last Thursday, objecting to the design, loss of existing retail space and its impact on the so-called West End Stress Area.

'The replacement design is very modern and uses a lot of glass and this was felt to be inappropriate for the local conservation area and the impact on the Grade II-listed building,' Westminster City Council case worker Josephine Palmer told the AJ.

'The committee also opposed the loss of 689m 2of retail floor space at second-floor level and 583m 2at basement level, and its effect on the West End Stress Area, in other words, that there were already a maximum number of restaurants in the area.'

Liberty declined to comment on whether or not it planned to appeal the council's decision.

by Clive Walker

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment.

The searchable digital buildings archive with drawings from more than 1,500 projects

AJ newsletters