By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

Your browser seems to have cookies disabled. For the best experience of this website, please enable cookies in your browser.


Your browser is no longer supported

For the best possible experience using our website we recommend you upgrade to a newer version or another browser.


Malcolm Fraser resigns from A&DS over PPP schools 'blight'

Malcolm Fraser has stepped down from his role as deputy chairman of Architecture and Design Scotland (A&DS) amid concerns that schools being built using private finance are 'blighting' schoolchildren's lives.

Award-winning architect Fraser said that schools being built through public-private partnership (PPP) have undergone 'catastrophically poor' design.

Fraser's comments come from a letter of resignation to Scottish Executive culture minister Patricia Ferguson, in which he questions whether such privately financed initiatives are value for money, and claims A&DS rejected his calls for an investigation into the matter.

'The general silence of the building industry on this issue is a disgrace,' he said. 'All know of its fundamental flaws, but there is a river of money flowing from it towards us so we keep schtum.'

Fraser added: 'I have seen nearly 100 of these schools and I saw 27 schools for the Highlands. This is the biggest single financial investment in the built infrastructure of the Highlands and the future of the people - and these schools are catastrophically poor.

'I'm not talking about design as a subjective thing, I'm talking about objective evidence-based design which says we are currently building schools right across the Highlands that will blight the lives of those that will learn in them.'

Fraser said he had been pushing for better design of schools within A&DS for the last two years.

'I've been fighting the cause for two years, and it was only when I realised that nothing was going to happen that I decided to hand my resignation in.'

Fraser's comments will be widely welcomed by architects in Scotland, not least by Alan Dunlop of GM&AD, although Dunlop claims it is a change of tack from Fraser.

Dunlop said: 'I'm happy Fraser has taken this stance but it has taken a while, when some of us have been speaking out about PPP for the last three years - putting our businesses at risk.

'I wrote a column in a national architectural publication last November saying how ineffective A&DS was and how they ignored the big issues like PPP. Fraser responded by saying I was an embarrassment - funny how things change.'

by Richard Vaughan

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment.

The searchable digital buildings archive with drawings from more than 1,500 projects

AJ newsletters