Norman Foster and Daniel Libeskind battle to extend Monaco into the sea

Norman Foster Daniel Libeskind

Norman Foster and Daniel Libeskind are leading the race to design Monaco extension

Norman Foster and Daniel Libeskind have come out as frontrunners in the battle to design an artificial extension to Monaco.

The two heavyweights are among five other bids competing for the high-profile commission, including a joint proposal from Frank Gehry and Rem Koolhaas.

However, it is understood Gehry and Koolhaas' scheme has become sidelined after it was described as being 'too grandiose and a little utopian' by the competition organisers.

Speaking to the Daily Telegraph, Monaco's prime minister Jean-Paul Proust said: 'It will have to look as if the extension had always been there.'

The Mediterranean tax haven became the focus of a design competition when the principality's ruler Prince Albert II invited bids back in 2006.

The Prince called for the world's playground for the rich and famous to be extended out into the sea, creating a peninsula approximately the size of 20 football pitches.

It is understood that the development plans have been estimated to cost anywhere between 5-10 billion euros (£4-8 billion), and will provide up to 275,000m2 of new housing and tourist facilities.

A winner will be chosen from the five bidders and the result is due to be announced by February next year. It is expected that work will begin by 2011 and will last 10 years.
 

 


Please note: In order to post a response you need to be registered on the site. You can register here.

Reader Response

Foster would definitely be the better choice for this critical development if it wasn’t for the fact that they are teamed up with Arquitectonica- a company with a portfolio of work that bolsters bold moves with no substance. It is quite an irony to even have a team consisted of two architectural companies with such opposite visions not only in terms of design sensibility but also commitment to quality, environmental sensitivity, not to mention the capability and technical expertise. Foster being the world renowned architectural firm with amazing track record of producing superior design and high quality buildings; and Arquitectonica better known for mostly average developer residential projects with architecture lacking in vigor, quality and sustainability (as evident by the low ratio of design proposals vs. built projects). This is quite a miss-match!!

I'm not surprised that Libeskind's museum is wasteful of energy. Evidence suggests that he is not the sort of person who cares much about detailing or the realities of building. His Museum in Denver leaked like a sieve. Ditto the subsequent museum in Toronto (which also suggests he does not care to learn from his mistakes). Libeskind was never more than a maker of shapes. He went from being a student to a star without ever having the benefit of real professional experience. I'm glad the AJ is exposing these problems with so-called premium designers.

Has anyone seen their proposed plans. Where can one see them?

Has anyone seen their proposed plans. Where can one see them?

Considering that Libeskind's Imperial War Museum was identified as an energy guzzler and received the LOWEST POSSIBLE ENERGY EFFICIENCY RATING, it is shocking to think of the wastage that might result were Libeskind to be awarded the huge project in Monaco. Even that wealthy principality could not afford incompetence on that scale.

Foster's talent and technical expertise will will the day. It's hard to imagine Daniel Libeskind knows ANYTHING about environmental design. For that matter, he doesn't seem to know much about architecture either. Libeskind remains the butt of all jokes for being the only architect who ever had to hire another architect to design his own home over in New York. (He was caught out lying to the New York Times when he claimed he designed it himself.) Once Prince Ranier starts talking to the guys in Studio Libeskinf he'll soon realize they are all flash image and no depth. Foster can bank on winning this one easily.