Zaha makes it on to the Stirling Prize shortlist for the third time

Nordpark

The Nordpark Cable Railway by Zaha Hadid

Zaha Hadid will be hoping to make it third time lucky after her Nordpark Cable Railway in Austria was named on the this year's Stirling shortlist.


Nordpark
Nordpark Cable Railway, by Zaha Hadid Architects


The Priztker Prize-winner, who had buildings on the 2005 and 2006 shortlists (the BMW Central Building in Leipzig and the Phaeno Science Centre in Wolfsburg respectively), is joined by fellow former finalist Grimshaw (Eden Project, 2001) with its Amsterdam Bijlmer Arena Station, drawn up in collaboration with Arcadis Architecten.

Bijlmer
Bijlmer Arena Station, by Grimshaw and Arcadis


The other four shortlisted schemes for UK architecture's most prestigious prize are: the Accordia housing scheme in Cambridge by Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios, Alison Brooks Architects and Maccreanor Lavington; the Manchester Civil Justice Centre, by Denton Corker Marshall; the revamp of the Royal Festival Hall, London, by Allies and Morrison; and Allford Hall Monaghan Morris' Westminster Academy at the Naim Dangoor Centre in London.

RIBAStirlingAccordia
Accordia, by Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios, Maccreanor Lavington and Alison Brooks Architects


The winner will be announced in Liverpool on 11 October. The shortlist for the Stirling Prize is drawn from the winners of the RIBA National Awards and the RIBA EU awards. The Architects' Journal is the main sponsor of the Stirling Prize.

RIBAStirlingManchesterCivilJustice
Manchester Civil Justice Centre, by Denton Corker Marshall

WestminsterAcademy
Westminster Academy at the Naim Dangoor Centre, by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris
RIBAStirlingRoyalFestivalHall
Royal Festival Hall, by Allies and Morrison

Please note: In order to post a response you need to be registered on the site. You can register here.

Reader Response

My vote is with DCM for a fabulous building in my home city. It is truly elegant and inspiring design one I am looking forward to seeing in the flesh on my next visit home.

i like Zaha, but she should have won for BMW, not this. My vote's for the Royal Festival Hall. I think A&M did a good work with the restoration of a beautiful building.

...What is it with gabions though? It's all over the place now!

dcm = dog's danglies

I think the winner should be the Manchester Civic Justice Centre, which is functional, elegant and poetic. It definitely stands out of the current trend and has its soul in it.

The Nordpark Cable Railway – looks fantastic but overdone; big names always get big money to build a small piece of artwork , but this is not architecture is about.
The Bijlmer Arena Station ………….?
Accordia - looks quite interesting but not so outstanding – again, overdone;
Westminster Academy at the Naim Dangoor Centre – definitely special and interesting, but not at this level.
Royal Festival Hall – overrated and not at this level. I quite like some of A&M’s buildings this is just as good as others.

Two horse race; Denton CM and Grimshaw. Zaha's is good, but not her best work.

It has to be A&M's Royal Festival Hall. A project that has not only sympathetically restored one of London's most spectactular public buildings, but has begun the gradual repair one of London's most diverse and rich strands of urban fabric.

My vote goes to the DCM Manchester scheme - it's superb, probably one of the finest civic buildings in Europe