Report: viability of on-site energy generation in offices ‘highly questionable’
A new report has blamed ‘contradictory’ government policy for office developers installing ‘very inefficient and badly performing’, small-scale renewable energy generators
Drawn up by Sturgis Carbon Profiling for the British Council for Offices (BCO), the document claims that the ‘perceived merits’ of reducing carbon emissions through on-site renewable is not cost effective compared to ‘alternative larger scale carbon reduction installations’.
In addition, due to the high taxpayer subsidies, the report warned it was ‘highly questionable whether advocating micro generation for commercial buildings in dense city centres [can be] justified’.
Although admitting some installations produce ‘modest financial returns’, the document said there were ‘cheaper options available that [could] deliver both carbon and cost savings more effectively.’
Gareth Roberts of Sturgis Carbon Profiling said: ‘[We have exposed] the contradictions in government policy in that currently Carbon Capture and Storage is viewed by many to be expensive and poor value for money, even though it costs only £40/T. [However] developers are routinely paying around £380/T on average to achieve the same goals [through on-site renewable]’.
‘With basic economic forces at play renewables would be much better deployed on land which is of low value and on a much larger scale than currently used on most commercial buildings.’
The report calls for a wider review of the costs of achieving carbon emissions throughout the built environment.
Roberts concluded: ‘To many developers on-site micro generation policies are simply viewed as another planning hurdle to cross.
‘Renewable installations are considered a cost to be minimized, given that the majority of their benefits will be passed on to future unknown tenants.
‘This misalignment of incentives however has the precise effect of compounding the specification of small badly performing installations, which generate little benefit to occupiers or the environment.’
Subscribe to AJ for £3 per week
Subscribe today and receive 47 issues of the magazine, 12 issues of AJ Specification and full access to TheAJ.co.uk and the AJ Buildings Library
Are you a student?
Students can subscribe to the AJ for £8 per month or £1.60 per week! Click here to start receiving the most recommended magazine for architecture students