Barnet Council has rejected Carey Jones' mixed-use Cricklewood Gate development in north London, claiming the proposed scheme did not integrate with the massive forthcoming regeneration in the area.
The authority also raised fears about the design and impact of the project, which would have created 474 flats, 1,880m2
of offices and 720m2
of leisure space on a former Parcelforce site at the gateway to the Brent Cross, Cricklewood and West Hendon regeneration zone.
According to the council, the proposed scheme, for developer Keystone, would have been detrimental to 'the appearance of the street scene' because of its mass, scale, bulk and design.
Intriguingly, it was also argued that the scheme was 'premature' and that the interim knock-on effects 'arising as a result of this development in advance of the comprehensive regeneration proposals for the area' would be harmful.
Prior to the council decision, CABE had given the proposals, conceived as a series of fingers, its muted support.
However, the watchdog too had its doubts, stating that some of the buildings were 'unnecessarily complicated' and that the rooftop details needed 'calming down'.
The practice refused to comment on the decision, and was unable to confirm whether the client was intending to appeal.by Richard Waite