Alan Dunlop's Comments
Comment on: Maggie’s Lanarkshire by Reiach and Hall
Beautiful, considered work.
Comment on: Stirling Prize shortlist: the critics react
mmm...me too Joe, Ortus looks like a stunning project.
Comment on: Are there too many architecture schools?
"I have now wandered though another raft of end- of-year shows which display huge endeavour and creativity...but exhibit endless unbuildable, unreal, irrelevant and ultimately forgettable projects that will evaporate as soon as the shows close." Sadly I have too, in the UK but also China and USA as critic, reviewer and also external examiner. Often brilliant cgi images and stunning drawings from cleary talented students of ultimately pointless projects.
Having just returned from Suzhou and this building, I believe this project would be a very relevant and informative case study for those architects interested in how things are done in China. Focusing on the high aspirations and design intent of the architect, compared to what the LDI's and contractors understand and are capable of delivering.
Why not use the currently vacant architecture studios of the Fielden building at Strathclyde University as much needed temporary studios for students of the GSA, while restoration work is undertaken. A generous offer of solidarity, respect and friendship from one great institution across the city to another needing help which will be a positive reuse of much respected Fielden building?
Why not use the currently vacant architecture studios of the Fielden building at Strathclyde University as much needed temporary studios for students of the GSA, while restoration work is undertaken. A generous offer of solidarity, respect and friendship from one great institution across the city to another needing help which will be a positive reuse of much respected Fielden building? http://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/news/anger-as-strathclyde-school-of-architecture-leaves-brutalist-home/8641156.article
Comment on: Glasgow School of Art by Steven Holl
Very good piece. It's true the critics have been negative, much of it I think as a consequence of the architect's metaphysical archibabble, which makes Kahn the personification of clarity and suspect post rationalisation. It's in it's relationship with the GSA and Holl's stated intention of an "homage" to Mackintosh, which became a " complementary contrast.....if you want to respect someone; you do the opposite" that the building is compromised and Holl left open to much criticism. It is undoubtedly a strong work of architecture. Considered and skillfully constructed and as this piece points out, Glasgow is the better for it.
Comment on: Red Road flats demolition 'spectacle' scrapped
I agree Matt, many of the "mistakes" of Red Road were down to mismanagement but don't necessarily agree that it has been deliberate and that Sam Bunton has been scapegoated to an extent. I also agree that there is nothing to applaud but the correct decision has now been made, for whatever the reason we should, as Glaswegians interested in promoting our city internationally, celebrate that.
forgive me .... but what on earth are you saying. Sorry, but this is drivel.
Grim? The choice of grey and black Petersen bricks and black pantiles are a bold move and will no doubt be controversial here. But this building is undoubtedly a work of Architecture. Intellectually satisfying on many levels, expertly considered and immaculately detailed, in my view.
Comment on: A world away: House No 7 by Denizen Works
Great review. Pleasure to read.
Good luck, a frankly bizarre decision to refuse.
Comment on: Learning from Glas Vegas
Great issue, clever ideas, excellent drawings. Well done
why is that worth pointing out?
Comment on: Sutherland Hussey unveils Shanghai gallery
Immaculate renders of what looks like a very interesting and contextual project. Good luck with it.
Comment on: Major breakthrough in PQQ reform
Excellent, long overdue.
Comment on: Are there too many architecture schools?
"I feel it is frankly immoral for schools to be producing unemployable graduates." Agreed and agreed also that there are too many schools. As for the most effective way of teaching architecture, I'd be interested to find out the number of the heads of these many schools are experienced in the craft of architecture, have actually built projects of some scale....... or at all.
Frankly, Glenn if you want to read a great article on the problems of architectural education read Austin Williams on sustainability supplanting critical engagement then Penny Lewis on the need for a core method and text, rooted in the study of history, context and culture and the modern movement.
Comment on: Daniel Libeskind lands Durham Uni jackpot
I think you should say what you really mean Respor.
Congratulations Bruce and good luck.
Not unconvinced at all.........actually pretty ambitious and I'm thankful for it.
Is there a site plan and plan(s)?
Kerr Robertson is an highly experienced architect and well regarded professional. The fact the RIAS acknowledge that the competition was well run is largly due to his input and direction. "whichever design won we would have gone with the public’s view." I don't recall this being made clear, if so why have a jury?
Congratulations SHA, a great project and build quality looks excellent.
Comment on: Work to start on 'less radical' George Sq revamp
Explosive right enough, well done RIAS..........wonder what the major issue was that arose during the judging and left the leader of the council increasingly agitated, the competition a shambles and Glasgow an international laughing stock?
Very nicely done, cleverly planned, good light from a narrow site and spatially very interesting. Congratulations.
Water features aside, Entry 2 seems to better understand the social, political and civic context of the square. That in my view is fundemental and suggest an architect that is very familiar with Glasgow and its history........it is also a fine proposal and that also seems to be reflected in the poll above.
Congratulations, Chris.......I'll look forward to seeing some more beautiful drawings.