Simon Carne's Comments
Lucy's comments are so sensible but architects just can't resist the thrill of the chase. Also surprising to see who is on the panel of judges. How will their deliberations be recorded in the interests of transparency and openness? At least there are a couple of 'relatively' small practices involved and so - good luck Marks Barfield.
Comment on: Cardiff: a city of big ideas
The critical importance of regional transport in the City Region should not be underplayed. Felix rightly points out the scale and population of a South Wales City region, but it is one that is crying out for greater employment opportunities. Transport for the region as a whole is required. Having looked for example at numerous projects large and small across Wales and in particular in the south, my overall impression is that welsh enthusiasm and skill is often denied by the lack of the urbanist's vision for these independent towns and cities who jealously guard their identity, but miss opportunities to work together. By all means celebrate history, culture and individuality but share the proceeds and collaborate.
Comment on: Sketch competiton longlist R - Z
Louis Helman answers the brief, but then he doesn't need an introduction. Hannah Carding answers it with humour. Is the brief the key or will technical expertise win? They are lovely but for those taking on the larger scale it is difficult to see how the sketches show the different ways in which we make our houses, neighbourhoods and cities our own. It's a tough task for the judges.
BREEAM "excellent" fully glazed south facing building saved by CHP. Is that a suitable model? All those bike spaces and showers waiting for a good local cycling infrastructure.
One aspect not mentioned in the First Look article was the apparently generous floor plan areas. The 4 bed houses seem to be nearly 200m2, the one bed flats just over 93m2 and the 2 bed flats about 107m2. These if correct are considerably in excess of the London Housing Space Standards and recommendations in the RIBA's Case for Space campaign.
Richard Rogers inspired -like it Agnieskza
It is well worth re-reading Parker Morris. It addresses so much more than space standards. Many of the recommendations are of course past their sell-by date, but within the text there are many gems. I have in my copy highlighted many, here are few - "It is important that these minimum space standards should not be taken as a maxima; they are nothing of the sort." Para 16 The adaptable house merits only one paragraph (29) but ends with the call. "We see the investigation of practical possibilities of doing it (adaptable housing) easily ....one of the most important lines of future research into the development of design and structure the sooner it is started the better" "The over-riding concern in designing with the car in mind must be to design for the pedestrian to stay alive....."para 200 89 pages long, arguably too many words and not enough diagrams but excellent value at 4/- from HMSO. Time to publish again on the web with metric and costs updated for inflation?
Whilst having buildings as part of the backdrop to a World Heritage site is not in itself unacceptable, surely the issues are also quality of public realm, a cut back to reveal the entrance to Waterloo Station, lack of enclosure to the enlarged public realm and the unrelieved elevational treatment. Big buildings require more subtlety and interrogation before approval.
A new model for rural development? Can the "rules" of urban design be broken? So many questions, I'm sure Jonathan has good answers.
Comment on: A typology of spans
Comment on: Manchester’s new sound
10,600 sq m, £19.4m even after rising to £26m looks exceptional value for money.
Comment on: Top 10: World's most spectacular modern churches
These churches were selected by Emporis. Not knowing who they were I thought I'd have a look and they are....The #1 provider of building data and construction projects worldwide! Says it all.
Comment on: Foster's fantastic plan isn't just an airport, it's a £50bn leap into our connected future
Foster's airport is also of course more than architecture as well. In fact it isn't architecture at all, but planning, so long decried as a profession by architects. If the UK was serious about planning (and for that matter architecture) then it might happen one day.
Comment on: Olympic stadium wrap set for Rio encore
article 25 are clever guys keep it up.
Brockholes should be there. Stadium is great as a piece of engineering and planning butt not great architecture. lyrics could win it as architecture and urban design all round subtlety. Looking back at previous short lists this is not a bad crop and with at least two or three worthy potential winners
thanks Christine I was looking at the magazine at the time!
Please can you print site plans as a matter of course. I visited the gallery about three years ago, before the extension works. It was great then and the changing levels were particularly well handled in the original. But following the plans as it is now difficult without the wider context. It looks brilliant and what value for money. More please.
Comment on: Long House by Dan Brill Architects, Winchester
Looks as though it was almost permitted development? A very clever and attractive solution.
Sustainable development? Just in time to beat the NPPF.
Knocking down perfectly good (arguably excellent) buildings that need an Urban Splash treatment. Re-building on virtually the same footprint. Such a waste and shortsighted. What is needed is a more "nuanced" approach.