HERZOG & DE MEURON SHOULD NOT BE CAST IN STONE
I wish to express my doubts about Herzog & de Meuron's scooping of the RIBA Gold Medal (AJ 05.10.06).
Certainly the practice's early architecture had some quality, but today its work has, in my opinion, become formalistic - opportunistic, full of luxury-shine governed by commerce!
As an example, the project for a high tower on the Schatzaep Davos in Grisons, Switzerland, illustrates no feeling for the mountainscape, is expensive and over-instrumented.
The idea of a tower is of course better than filling the whole mountainside with 'kitsch' chalets, but Herzog & de Meuron's scheme is out of place.
I am dismayed to think that its name will be inscribed in the stone wall of the RIBA together with those of the truly great: Jack Coia, Michael Scott, Le Corbusier etc.
Bryan Cyril Thurston, Ürikon, Switzerland