By continuing to use the site you agree to our Privacy & Cookies policy

BOOKS

REVIEW

The Scottish Parliament By Charles Jencks.

Scala, 2005. 64pp. £4.95 Walker Art Center By Cathy Madison.

Scala, 2005. 64pp. £4.95 Scala publishes excellent guidebooks in various formats but the volumes in its Art Spaces series are truly pocket-sized - just 110 x 165mm, writes Andrew Mead.

About a dozen have appeared so far on buildings old and new, including the Guggenheim Bilbao, the Musée d'Orsay and the New York Public Library.

Cathy Madison gives a straightforward factual account of the evolution of the Walker Art Center - its origin as a private collection housed in a Minneapolis mansion, its move to a new building behind a 1920s Moorish facade, the fine Modernist replacement by Edward Larrabee Barnes in 1971, and the good-in-parts new addition by Herzog & de Meuron, which opened in April (AJ 14.04.05).

Jencks' text is of a different order, with a much more acute analysis of 'one of the most interesting, vilified, costly and marvellous buildings of our time' - Miralles' Scottish Parliament. As that comment implies, he's a fan. Accepting that many people will be 'confused and annoyed' when first faced with the 'complexity and richness' of the building, he's a persuasive advocate of its qualities (although there's a lot of persuading to do). Like Neil Gillespie in AJ 30.09.04, he finds 'poetry' in it.

Both books are generously illustrated, but Madison's edition on the Walker suffers from a rush to coincide with the opening of the new addition, and is consequently presented in an unfinished state. At such slight cost, though, you can't really argue.

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment.

The searchable digital buildings archive with drawings from more than 1,500 projects

AJ newsletters